Is the Pope infallible?

Papal infallibility, which emerged in the 13th and 14th centuries, has been Catholic dogma since 1870. The Reformers rejected it in the name of Scripture.

For the Catholic Church, yes: papal infallibility was defined as dogma in 1870. The Churches that came out of the Reformation reject it: for them, no human authority can place itself above Scripture. To understand this disagreement, we need to see how the idea arose and what logic supports it.

An authority built over time

Under the emperor Constantine, in the fourth century, the papacy as it would later be known did not yet exist. It developed between the middle of the third century and the accession of Gregory the Great in 590, notably under Leo I. The bishop of Rome, regarded as the successor of Peter according to Matthew 16:18-19, gradually became the head of the whole Western Church.

The idea of papal infallibility emerged in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. The pope also held temporal power, and being declared a heretic then meant being excluded from the whole of society. The authority to interpret became concentrated in the hands of one man. Unity of faith was easier to guarantee, but the place of Scripture receded.

The Catholic logic

The Catholic argument deserves to be presented seriously. A text does not interpret itself. When opposing readings arise, who decides? For Catholic theology, Christ entrusted his Church, and in particular the successors of Peter and the apostles, with the mission of faithfully guarding and interpreting revelation, with the help of the Holy Spirit.

From this perspective, the Magisterium, the teaching authority of the Church, is not above the word of God but at its service. This is what the Second Vatican Council affirms in Dei Verbum (1965).

The Reformers’ objection

Luther first challenged the sale of indulgences, then the authority that justified them. In 1518, when Cardinal Cajetan set a papal bull against him, he refused: a human decision, even a papal one, cannot prevail over Scripture. In 1520, he asked a direct question: if the pope could never be wrong, what would the Scriptures be for?

The principle of Sola Scriptura does not mean reading the Bible without an interpreter. It means that no interpreter, not even the pope, stands above the text. This is the position of this course.

Yet Catholics and Protestants share more than people think: the conviction that Scripture is the word of God and that it is read within the communion of the Church. Their disagreement is about one precise question: who has the last word?

Read also

All questions →