To read a text allegorically is to look in it for a deeper meaning than what it says at first sight. The characters, places or objects of a story then become images of another, spiritual reality. This way of reading is very old: it is already found in Paul, then in the Church Fathers and throughout the Middle Ages.
Already in the New Testament
Paul reads the Old Testament in several ways. One of them is allegorical: in Galatians 4:21-31, Hagar and Sarah become two covenants. This is only one of at least six methods he uses, alongside literal reading and the “how much more” argument.
The first Christians were also convinced that the prophecies were mysteries whose solution awaited the time of Christ. This idea prepared the ground for allegory, which later became very popular.
Why the Fathers loved it
For Irenaeus of Lyon (second century), it is not only a man who speaks in Scripture, but the Word of God and his Spirit. So the text can contain more than its human author had in mind.
Origen (third century) goes further. The Scriptures, he writes, “were written by the Spirit of God, and have a meaning, not such only as is apparent at first sight, but also another, which escapes the notice of most”. For him, allegory gives access to this hidden meaning, and such reading is only possible within the Church.
In the Middle Ages, these intuitions were organised into the four senses of Scripture. Take Jerusalem: in the literal sense, it is a city; in the allegorical sense, the Church; in the moral sense, the faithful soul; in the anagogical sense, the heavenly city.
The risk, and the safeguards
Allegory nourished centuries of prayer and preaching. But it carries a risk: letting the spiritual meaning drift away from what the text actually says. So the early Church set up safeguards. The rule of faith, a summary of the gospel learned before baptism, ruled out any interpretation that contradicted it. Augustine added that the whole of Scripture aims at the love of God and neighbour: a reading that does not make this love grow has not understood the text.
In the sixteenth century, the humanists and the Reformers reacted. From around 1519, Luther gave priority to the literal sense, properly understood, as the way to the meaning God intended.
For this course, the Bible is first of all a book of theology, to be read with sound methods: an entirely literal reading is dangerous, and so is an entirely allegorical one.
