What happened at the Council of Trent?

Opened in 1545, the Council of Trent answered the Reformers on four points: the canon, tradition, the reference Bible and interpretation.

The Council of Trent was the Catholic Church’s great response to the Protestant Reformation. Opened in 1545 by Pope Paul III, it met until 1563. According to the historian Victor Baroni, it had to settle four questions, all linked to the authority of Scripture.

The background

By challenging the sale of indulgences, Luther challenged the authority that justified them. For him, no human authority, not even the pope’s, can surpass Scripture: this is the principle of Sola Scriptura. The Reformers also rejected several books of the Old Testament, the deuterocanonical books. They wanted to go back to the Hebrew and Greek texts and to translate the Bible into the language of the people. So the Catholic Church had to state its position clearly.

The four decisions

  1. The limits of the canon. The Reformers rejected the deuterocanonical books; Trent confirmed them. This is why the Old Testament today has 46 books for Catholics and 39 for Protestants.
  2. The place of tradition. Trent affirmed that revelation is contained in the written books and in unwritten traditions.
  3. The reference Bible. Should the Latin Vulgate be followed, or the original texts? Trent declared the Vulgate authentic for the public use of the Church.
  4. Interpretation. No one may interpret Scripture against the sense held by the Church.

Two views of tradition

The Protestant theologian Keith Mathison, drawing on the historian Heiko Oberman, offers a useful framework. He distinguishes “Tradition I”, in which Scripture is the only source of revelation, interpreted in the Church and according to the rule of faith, and “Tradition II”, in which tradition becomes a second source of revelation alongside Scripture. In his view, Trent leans towards the second, whereas the Reformers wanted to return to the first, which he considers to be that of the early Church. This reading is disputed by Catholic theologians, but it helps to locate the debate.

What Trent settled

With Trent, the disagreement between Catholics and Protestants became lasting, both over the list of books and over the question of authority. Yet both sides share the conviction that Scripture is the word of God and that it is read within the communion of the Church. What divides them is the question of who has the last word in interpreting it. Later, the Second Vatican Council, in Dei Verbum (1965), would state that the Magisterium is not above the word of God but at its service.

Read also

All questions →